• Home
  • Posts RSS
  • Comments RSS
  • Edit
Blue Orange Green Pink Purple

In my world

Nachos are a health food. 5 am doesn't exist except for sleeping. I always have exactly what I need to complete a recipe. I never overcook the meal. Breakfast can be eaten at anytime of the day. Dishes clean themselves. Morning breath is always minty and fresh. Work does not start until at least 11 am. Even when I'm wrong, it sounds right. Cars emit bubbles that smell like flowers. Cats are always cuddly. Dog poo instantly transforms into dirt. The weather is never under 32 degrees. Each beach has fancy sea shells to collect. Sisters never fight. My imperfectly perfect man has already found and adores me. This man loves to do laundry. My hair looks perfect right out of the shower. Everyone knows I'm clever. Extra cheese is not asked, it's assumed.

Yoga, yoga, yoga.

Well little did I know, but yoga seems to be quite controversial within the Church. Obviously, I now know that yoga is a Hindu based practice. Ok. I mean, I knew Catholics didn't invent it. But I justify to myself that doing yoga at the gym is not practicing Hindu. I mean, my yoga teacher is definitely not Hindu. So what about this Chakra thing? Is that Hindu? Because she definitely talks about Chakra. Am I inadvertently being taught Hindu practices? Well ... I'm still looking. But this article seems pretty clear.

So my next justification is that I know that yoga has been shown to improve the health of your body. So is there yoga exercise that does not involve Hindu spiritual ties? Well, so far the Catholic church has not said NO, you can not practice yoga. A yoga like pose is fine as long as it is not combined with Hindu teachings.

But this seems pretty solid logic:
"BOTTOMLINE: There are risks in performing Yoga, even if you think you are only doing exercise. There are spiritual ramifications. Besides, why use Yoga, why take the risk? There are plenty of exercise routines that have no spiritual risk." - Catholics - Yoga

Well damn. What to do now? I mean, I know a lot of people who practice, or have practiced yoga. The Church does not say you can not. But if I listen to my instincts, as I already mentioned in the last blog, it was weird being told to picture a chord attaching yourself from your root chakra to the center of the earth.

And it is a yoga and meditation class. Which can be controversial as well. But I know the Church has done meditation. I mean I spent many hours going to class with Jill for Centering Prayer at our parish, which was essentially, meditating. And there was not talk during yoga class meditation of religious beliefs. Just energy and listening to your thoughts.

Ah well, we will see. I'll keep looking into it. As of yet, I'm not against continuing classes. It felt good. I haven't found harm in it yet. And it's not always an evil trick just because it feels good. But I am more skeptical. I wonder if this turns out to be more hype than truth whether my skepticism will ruin some of the purity of the exercise.

And is it just an exercise? Many of the things I have looked into so far are very clear that you can not "Christianize" yoga. Meaning, you can not simply change what you are thinking about to include your own beliefs. They believe the poses are meant to tune or open up your bodies energy to that of the earth or universe. Hmm. Does that mean Hindu spirits? Or just the energy of the Earth. Because Catholic or not, I still believe there is energy in the world that affects all living things. Am I silly to think that God would warn about poses the body could assume that will invoke spirits other than his own? I mean, who needs to "Christianize" yoga anyway? If it's an exercise (created by whomever) for the body, that shows positive results, can't it just be an exercise? Cuz I enjoy it more than pilates, or kickboxing. And quiet frankly I don't really involve spiritual anything into my work out routine. Why would I during yoga?

And am I just trying to ask questions to get to an answer I want to hear?

Food for thought.
Read More 9 comments | Posted by erin edit post

9 comments

  1. Dan on 12:33 AM, January 09, 2010

    Yea, that's a lot of questions. I'm sure there's no reason yoga as physical exercise and Christianity must remain mutually exclusive. Of course, it does depend on what the instructor is propagating.

    Keep us updated.

     
  2. Viewtiful_Justin on 9:51 AM, January 09, 2010

    I think it's silly to think that an exercise could ruin your faith. If God is God, which I believe he is, then he's bigger than yoga. If your faith could be shaken by an exercise, then yoga isn't your biggest problem.

     
  3. M on 9:58 AM, January 09, 2010

    Oh, okay. @Justin: It is our responsibility as Christians to avoid all temptation. Of course He is bigger than yoga. However it is more prudent to select an exercise routine in which you are not "opening your mind" to even the slightest blasphemy.

    For the record, I did utilize yoga for many years and found it to be very helpful during my pregnancies. But I chose a studio that was focused on fitness not on spirituality. Of course, you can be discerning and still reap the health benefits of yoga, but do not underestimate the small ways that Satan will lead you astray in your adult life.

    Okay, I'm done now!

     
  4. Viewtiful_Justin on 10:05 AM, January 09, 2010

    I'm sorry...I realized after I posted it that that sounded kind of rude. I didn't in any way mean for it to sound that way. I don't think you're silly for asking questions about this.

     
  5. Viewtiful_Justin on 10:06 AM, January 09, 2010

    @ M - True story. But if she's not tempted by the spiritual aspect at all, then wouldn't going be of no harm at all?

     
  6. M on 8:53 PM, January 09, 2010

    I think it depends. I would argue that it is more responsible to avoid a questionable situation. You would have to define "no harm at all" in order for me to really answer this.

    But, from what she has described here, her instructor is already discussing a journey through the chakras. Chakras are very rooted in Hindu spirituality. I think it is our responsibility as Christians to learn about many different religions so that we can effectively minister to many people. However, putting yourself in a suggestive environment and opening up your mind and body's energy to be receptive to those non-Christian religions is a different thing.

     
  7. Viewtiful_Justin on 11:55 AM, January 10, 2010

    Well, to each their own, I guess.

     
  8. M on 5:24 PM, January 10, 2010

    Ah, a bit of moral relativity? :)

     
  9. erin on 2:18 PM, January 11, 2010

    Hmm. I suppose it's contraversial in the Church and on the blog. Hehe. ;) Thanks for the thoughts. I'm still deciding on this class. We will see what Thursday has to bring.

     


Post a Comment
Newer Post Older Post Home

Followers

polaroid pages~

word captured, satisfaction guaranteed:
    • I live, I laugh, I cry, I dance, I dream.


  • Blog Archive

    • ► 2023 (2)
      • ► March (2)
    • ► 2013 (10)
      • ► April (3)
      • ► January (7)
    • ► 2012 (2)
      • ► October (1)
      • ► July (1)
    • ► 2011 (36)
      • ► September (1)
      • ► August (1)
      • ► July (2)
      • ► June (1)
      • ► May (1)
      • ► April (5)
      • ► March (11)
      • ► February (9)
      • ► January (5)
    • ▼ 2010 (132)
      • ► November (5)
      • ► October (7)
      • ► September (8)
      • ► August (9)
      • ► July (11)
      • ► June (14)
      • ► May (11)
      • ► April (3)
      • ► March (14)
      • ► February (24)
      • ▼ January (26)
        • How far
        • Well that didn't last very long ...
        • Two-fer Tuesday
        • The truth is ...
        • Oh Monday ...
        • Pick me up buttercup
        • The good's, the bad's, the ugly's
        • Sometimes, a girl just has to know how special she...
        • Wordless Wednesday
        • Last night I did not brush my teeth.
        • With reckless abandon
        • Recipe for disaster
        • When it comes to Jelly Bellys, anything is worth t...
        • Thankful Thursdays
        • Wordless Wednesday
        • Truthful Tuesdays
        • Moody Monday
        • Fancy Schmancy
        • Yoga, yoga, yoga.
        • Namaste
        • D to the A to the N
        • ::slap:: ::slap:: I challenge you to a duel!
        • Ok, ok. I started it.
        • Dear Mom
        • Year in a Word
        • I love potatoes.
    • ► 2009 (91)
      • ► December (2)
      • ► November (5)
      • ► October (6)
      • ► September (3)
      • ► August (5)
      • ► July (3)
      • ► June (9)
      • ► May (8)
      • ► April (14)
      • ► March (2)
      • ► February (16)
      • ► January (18)
    • ► 2008 (61)
      • ► December (7)
      • ► November (15)
      • ► October (3)
      • ► June (1)
      • ► May (2)
      • ► April (3)
      • ► March (7)
      • ► February (11)
      • ► January (12)
    • ► 2007 (110)
      • ► December (5)
      • ► November (18)
      • ► October (14)
      • ► September (1)
      • ► August (11)
      • ► July (38)
      • ► June (23)
    • ► 2006 (27)
      • ► December (1)
      • ► November (26)

    I have bursts of being a lady, but they don't last long.

    Bloggedy Blogs

    • Twinner
    • Lego-me-Mego
    • Kit Kat
    • My AK girl
    • Aunt G
    • Bubba
    • IL Flavor

    Favorite Quotes:

    "After all, if it were Cleverness that counted most, Rabbit would be Number One, instead of that Bear. But that's not the way things work."
    ~ The Tao of Pooh

    "ASAP. Whatever that means. It must mean, 'Act swiftly awesome pacaderm!'"
    ~ Dr. Seuss

    "Sometimes, when I laugh, my boogers come out a little bit."
    ~ My niece Gilly

    Labels

    • All the other stuff (23)
    • Free Friday (17)
    • I'm funnier than you think I am (16)
    • Little notes (21)
    • Moody Monday (5)
    • Not Me Monday (13)
    • NRS (8)
    • Poet me this (38)
    • Thankful Thursdays (16)
    • Truthful Tuesdays (19)
    • Wordless Wednesday (17)

    Search This Blog

  • Search






    • Home
    • Posts RSS
    • Comments RSS
    • Edit

    © Copyright Polaroid Pages. All rights reserved.
    Designed by FTL Wordpress Themes | Bloggerized by FalconHive.com
    brought to you by Smashing Magazine

    Back to Top